Is it Okay to Test God’s Voice with a Fleece?

Sometimes Christians use the phrase “using a fleece” when they ask God for something specific while seeking His direction. But should we? [This post is part of A Biblical Foundation to Hearing God’s Voice series]


A series on hearing God’s voice wouldn’t be complete without bringing up the subject of “using a fleece.” What are “fleeces,” you ask? Sometimes Christians use the phrase “using a fleece” when they ask God for something specific while seeking His direction, and test Him just like Gideon did.

The story of Gideon’s fleeces can be found in Judges 6:11-40, but there’s a small portion of that I want us to zero in on. Before we look at that you may need a recap of the story, so I’ll sum it up for you. You’re welcome. 😉

An Average Joe

The children of Israel hadn’t obeyed the Lord so they were being oppressed by the Midianites. The angel of the Lord appeared to an average Joe named Gideon, who was least in his father’s house (human thinking) although God said he was a mighty man of valor (Kingdom thinking). An angel was standing there talking to him, and he was saying, “Wait, I need a sign that you’re an angel standing here talking to me.” (God 1, Gideon 0)

So Gideon whipped up some grub, and the angel said put it on the rock. The angel supernaturally set it on fire and left Gideon blinking to himself, “Whoa that was an angel standing here talking to me.” (God 2, Gideon 1.) But I can relate to Gideon; I’m a slow learner sometimes, too.

Then God talked to Gideon a couple of times and gave him specific directions to tear down the altar of Baal. He did this at night, since he was too chicken to do it during the day. Hmm, Gideon heard God’s voice and obeyed it. (God 3, Gideon 2)

Next, the Spirit of the Lord came on Gideon, and he started issuing orders to bring in recruitments against the war the Midianites were trying to start. (God 4, Gideon 3)

Gideon’s Fleece

And that brings us up to the part that we are talking about today: using a fleece.

Then Gideon said to God, “If you are truly going to use me to rescue Israel as you promised, prove it to me in this way. I will put a wool fleece on the threshing floor tonight. If the fleece is wet with dew in the morning but the ground is dry, then I will know that you are going to help me rescue Israel as you promised.” And that is just what happened. When Gideon got up early the next morning, he squeezed the fleece and wrung out a whole bowlful of water.

Then Gideon said to God, “Please don’t be angry with me, but let me make one more request. Let me use the fleece for one more test. This time let the fleece remain dry while the ground around it is wet with dew.” So that night God did as Gideon asked. The fleece was dry in the morning, but the ground was covered with dew. Judges 6:36-40 NLT

Say what? After seeing an angel and all this interaction with the voice of the Lord now you’re going to test God, Gideon? What happened?

When Gideon did this, he was overtaken with doubt. Questioning God is okay, but it does not seem wise to do so in the sense of doubting God.

The Spirit of God came on him when he blew the horn, but he had weak faith. He’s dictating terms with God with those fleeces. But this shows God’s patience. —TJ Hall

Gideon was just like us. Real. We struggle with doubt. We want to know that we know. Once God has told us to do something, a focus on obeying rather than doubting is better.

Sometimes Christians use the phrase “using a fleece” when they ask God for something specific while seeking His direction. But should we?

What About Today? Should Christians Use Fleeces?

We don’t see the Apostle Paul putting up fleeces. Why not? Well, not only was Paul’s spiritual maturity level greater than Gideon’s, but today we have the Holy Spirit within us. Gideon didn’t  have that benefit. (We only see a few instances where the Holy Spirit came to move on someone in the Old Testament.)

My pastor touched on this subject a bit in one of his messages. In my notes, I wrote down five reasons we probably shouldn’t use a fleece:

  • Zachariah asked for a confirming sign, and the result was he was mute for awhile (Luke 1:18-22)
  • Jesus said a wicked generation asks for a sign (Matthew 16:4)
  • We have the complete Word of God
  • We have the Holy Spirit Himself in our heart to guide and correct (John 14:17, 16:13)
  • When we believe, signs follow (Mark 16:17).
Sometimes Christians use the phrase “using a fleece” when they ask God for something specific while seeking His direction. But should we? #ThrivingInChrist #LiveYielded Click To Tweet

Fleeces and Praying About a Relationship

I knew a couple of young adults that liked each other, but weren’t in an official relationship. The guy prayed and asked God to show him if he was supposed to marry her. They met at work; he was fulltime and she was hired via temporary contract. He “put up a fleece” that if she came back to his work that month, then God was saying yes. If she didn’t show up, the answer was no.

They had mutual friends at the same job, and one day that month, she dropped by to give one of her friends a ride home. He happened to see her and was ecstatic. When he relayed the prayer with the fleece, she wasn’t happy about it at all. She didn’t want to marry him.

Now clearly, what happened was coincidence, not God answering a superstitious prayer. Using a fleece is not a good idea when it concerns relationships. He walked away from God because he didn’t get the girl, and his life went downhill for a long time after that. That’s as much as I know before I lost touch with them.

Using a fleece may be doable in certain cases, but wisdom seems to cry that it’s not God’s best. I would be more inclined to discern God’s voice concerning a relationship and look for confirmations instead of using a fleece.

Should We Test God?

Putting up a fleece is essentially testing God. What does the Bible say about testing Him? Here are some verses to consider:

  1. Test the spirit when we hear a voice. “Dear friends, do not believe everyone who claims to speak by the Spirit. You must test them to see if the spirit they have comes from God. For there are many false prophets in the world.” 1 John 4:1 NLT
  2. Prove God, in the sense of standing in faith (Malachi 3:10).
  3. Not tempt God (Matthew 4:7) which means “to put to proof God’s character and power.” This means in the sense of manipulating God.

When it comes to hearing God’s voice and knowing His will, don’t overthink it. It’s better to trust Him and believe in His ability to lead us, than being fearful that we’re going to miss Him.

Simply invite God into your day and into your decisions. He’s going to have wisdom and insight to bless you. Sometimes it is going to be super obvious how He’s leading you. Other times it’s going to seem like you’re left to make a decision. So make it. And you will still see His blessing.

What do you think? Should Christians use a fleece?

Next Steps

Similar Posts

14 Comments

  1. Excellent post! I haven’t heard of this topic touched on in years. I have always thought of the idea of using a “fleece” was a bit immature and a sign of lack of faith in God. Thanks for explaining this in such a simple way!

    1. kellyrbaker says:

      You may be surprised how many Christians seek for a sign rather than seeking God’s voice and trusting Him. Thanks for stopping by, Summer!

  2. When I was a young christian I used to do this all the time. Thank God for His Holy Spirit that is always teaching us and growing us. This is an excellent post, I’m so thankful you are teaching other christians the truth behind the “fleece”.

    1. kellyrbaker says:

      Thanks for your kind comment, Carolina. Yes, thank God that He continues to bring us into a greater maturity of walking with Him. There is grace, but I felt the subject needed to be addressed.

  3. Hi Kelly,
    As a woman who sometimes struggles with the big decisions, I can empathize with Gideon. But, today’s believers are at an advantage–we have the Holy Spirit to provide counsel. While I have presented God with my own “fleece” before, I’m growing in my trust as I’ve learned to better discern His voice.

    Thanks for this thought provoking post!

    Blessings,
    Tammy

    1. kellyrbaker says:

      I have definitely done so as well in the days of being a young Believer. And I have thought many times that I’m glad I wasn’t Gideon. 😉 Thanks for stopping by, Tammy!

  4. I very much agree with you on this Kelly. The more we seek to hear God’s voice, the more we will here it. Taking those moments to pause and listen can be so very important
    He guides us at times subtly but at times loud and clear. Reading from #teaandword

    1. kellyrbaker says:

      Yes! In this day and age, being still might just make all the difference! Thanks, April

  5. Such a great post–I really enjoyed your summary! “When we believe, signs follow (Mark 16:17)”–how true and well said. I’ve never “used a fleece” (that I can remember), but I have asked that God give me confirmations along the way in something I was hesitant about. Most of the time that confirmation came during prayer and not from some outside source.

    1. kellyrbaker says:

      Glad you enjoyed it, Amanda! I’ve experienced confirmations through prayer as well.

  6. I really enjoyed this post. I can certainly say that I no longer use a fleece, but in my early days of grief after the death of my best friend, I constantly asked God for a sign that He was near and that all was okay, that I would be okay. While I didn’t ask for specific things, I did request ‘proof’ of God. The story of Gideon actually comforted me in that Gideon kept getting his signs. I knew that I couldn’t stay in that place of asking God to prove Himself and that it was a matter of strengthening my faith in Him. However, I’m so thankful the Lord was patient with me and allowed me that time to question and search. Thank you for this post as I’ve enjoyed contemplating my journey and being reminded of how faithful the Lord is when we are faithful to Him.

  7. I enjoyed this post, Kelly. It’s been quite a long time since I’ve heard a message concerning ‘fleeces.’ Thanks for sharing it again. To answer your question about whether Christians should use fleeces, I don’t believe we should. We have the Holy Spirit to guide us when we ask for His help on what to do. And with that, we are to believe that when we ask for help, that He will give it to us and not question God or test Him. Again, you’ve written a great post and an excellent series on knowing God’s will. Blessings to you!

  8. This is some sound teaching, Kelly. I appreciate how you dig right in and offer several pieces of Scripture to support what you are saying. I am so thankful that God gave us the gift of the Holy Spirit to lead and guide us, so we don’t need to test God with a ‘fleece’. When we are in tune with Him, abiding in Him, our hearts will come into alignment with His. Thank you for sharing this Biblical point of view!

    1. kellyrbaker says:

      Yes, abiding is key! Thanks, Aimee!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.